Some business costs are obvious: salaries, technology investments, operational expenses. Others remain hidden, buried inside inefficiencies that drain time, limit growth, and quietly erode profitability.
For many group benefits carriers, manual rating and pricing isn’t seen as an “expense” at all. It’s just the way things have always been done. But every manual adjustment, every spreadsheet update, every back-and-forth pricing round represents a silent tax – one that keeps compounding as your business grows.
The True Cost of Manual Rating & Pricing
The cost of inefficiency in your rating and pricing workflows isn’t always obvious but it can add up over time. Pricing cycles that stretch into weeks or months create a perpetual drain that impacts every aspect of your business.
Here’s how the “silent tax” of manual pricing hurts carriers:
1. Lost Time Equals Lost Revenue
Every benefit or budget negotiation triggers a cascade of repricing updates – eating into sales, actuarial, underwriting, and operations teams’ time. This slow, iterative process creates friction and delays your speed-to-market.
2. Top Talent Trapped in Tactical Work
Your actuaries and underwriters represent some of your most valuable strategic resources. Yet manual pricing processes force them to spend countless hours on basic data entry and spreadsheet maintenance – time that could better be spent on:
- Developing innovative pricing strategies
- Creating more sophisticated product models
- Analyzing market trends and opportunities
- Building competitive advantages
3. Manual Errors Increase Risk
With every manual step in your process, the likelihood of errors increases:
- Mispriced quotes can mean lost revenue opportunities or profit leakage.
- Data inconsistencies erode trust with brokers and employers.
- Version control issues increase compliance concerns.
4. Growth Becomes a Bottleneck
If your pricing process is anchored in manual effort, scalability becomes difficult. Manual workflows don’t just slow down today’s deals – they limit your ability to handle increasing volume without adding headcount or operational overhead to your business.
The Compounding Impact on Your Business
Group benefits pricing is an annual exercise, making any inefficiency experienced exponentially more expensive for the carrier over time.
Consider this:
When actuaries and underwriters spend 30-40% of their time on manual repricing and data entry each year, that investment isn't a one-time hit – it's an expense that recurs and grows as your book of business expands. The more you scale, the heavier the burden becomes, creating a negative feedback loop that constrains growth precisely when acceleration is needed.
And the cost isn't just in time spent.
The more you grow, the more inefficiencies multiply, making future automation even harder.
While manual pricing may seem manageable today, it limits a carrier’s ability to develop more sophisticated pricing strategies, forcing your business to rely on static, one-size-fits-all rating models. Without automation, each quote must use broad assumptions rather than dynamic risk assessments – ultimately leading to missed revenue opportunities and pricing inefficiencies that compound year over year.
Meanwhile, competitors who have embraced automation are pulling ahead – saving time and winning business before you can even submit a quote.
But just as inefficiencies compound, so do the benefits of automation.
The more you grow, the more inefficiencies multiply, making future automation even harder.
By automating your rating and pricing processes once, you set in motion a flywheel of financial benefits that grows with every renewal cycle:
- Initial automation investment creates immediate efficiency gains
- Efficiencies multiply with each renewal cycle
- Business scales without a corresponding increase in manual effort
- Resources shift to strategic pricing innovations
When a carrier commits to automation today, they’re building the foundation for real-time, sophisticated pricing decisions. Each new group census can be treated dynamically, with pricing tailored to unique characteristics and risk profiles rather than forced into a generic model.
Here’s the question every carrier should be asking:
What would your team do with 30% more time each year?
Freed from the constraints of manual adjustments, they could drive strategic initiatives, optimize pricing models, and ultimately, boost your bottom line – turning automation into a competitive advantage rather than just an operational fix.
Automating What You Already Know & Trust with Coherent Spark
Traditional automation used to mean ripping out existing systems or replacing Excel-based pricing models – a disruption that introduced complexity and uncertainty. For many carriers, the cost and effort of overhauling their pricing infrastructure outweighed the potential benefits.
Today, automation doesn’t have to be disruptive. Modern solutions like Coherent Spark focus on enhancing existing workflows, eliminating inefficiencies without forcing a complete overhaul.
Coherent Spark eliminates the silent tax of manual pricing while keeping actuaries and underwriters in control of their models.
.png?width=1920&height=800&name=Group%20Benefits%20Infographic%20(1).png)
By seamlessly integrating with existing processes, Coherent Spark transforms slow, manual rating and pricing workflow into a streamlined, scalable system that delivers immediate and long-term ROI. No IT overhauls or rebuilding your pricing models from scratch.
With Coherent Spark, you unlock:
- Faster Rating, Smarter Pricing – Automate census data input and rating calculations so quotes are generated in seconds, not days.
- Fewer Errors, Less Rework – No more copy-pasting between spreadsheets and pricing systems – Use Coherent Spark’s API to seamlessly plug into your core systems, reducing errors and ensuring compliance.
- Lower Overhead, Higher ROI – Handling increased volume doesn’t require more headcount, just a better system.
- Minimal Disruption, Maximum Impact – Coherent Spark integrates with existing Excel-based workflows, meaning no IT overhauls or rebuilding models from scratch.
Time to Eliminate the Silent Tax
The era of manual rating and pricing is coming to an end.
Carriers who cling to outdated processes risk falling behind competitors who can price faster, respond more quickly to brokers and employers, and ultimately, close deals more efficiently.
The real question isn’t “Should we automate?”
It’s “How much are we losing by not automating?”
Don't let the silent tax of manual processes continue draining your resources and limiting your growth. Transform your pricing workflow into a competitive advantage with Coherent Spark.
